LMS vs. PLE vs. OLN

I do not feel that I would have ever embraced the idea of a true PLE or the creation of a OLN if I had not taken this course.  Granted, I have used wikis, blogs, You Tube creations as well as other social networks in my classes.  Most of these, with the exception of You Tube, were part of a larger LMS provided by my employer.  They were secure, exclusive and protected.  They also existed for a finite period of time.  To progress to an open learning network and use Edupunk concepts really makes me ponder the future of what learning will become or more importantly how will it occur!

Am I ready for such a shift to learning with such a technological approach?  Certain arguments that promote Edupunk (PLE, OLN)  make total sense to me.   Jon Mott’s blog reports that more flexibility, an open environment, lower cost and engaging more learners are concepts that are hard to refute.  An engaged learner has the Web as his classroom and is limited by only his own desire to learn.  Is this education utopia?  I am excited by this concept and consequently must be an Edupunk!    Or am I?

The other side of me says NO!  A structured LMS is needed to address those administrative details that do not lend themselves to such an open environment.  A gradebook is such an example.  Private, secure lines of communication is another.  Some say that most individuals do not use all of the features of a LMS and if they did then the need for PLE and Edupunk is diminished.

Interestingly, I had a discussion with my students regarding this topic – LMS vs PLE and Edupunk.  I wanted to know their thoughts about this evolution in learning.  The majority stated that they prefered the traditional approach of the LMS versus Edupunk.  The major reason cited was the time that would needed to create the learning environment.  In addition many are not computer literate unless Facebook etc. is the network of choice.  I feel that if the concept of Edupunk/ PLE is incorporated early into a student’s education, acceptance would be forthcoming.


About macrtblog

Instructor - Delaware Tech
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to LMS vs. PLE vs. OLN

  1. williamboyer says:

    Hmmm, it’s interesting that you asked your students about these topics. It makes me wonder whether mine know about “EduPunk” or OLNs,PLEs, etc.

    Isn’t it interesting just how computer illiterate many students really are. Sure they know how to turn it on and click on a link, but ask them to do anything more than post to Facebook and they are lost! As an experiment, have them download a file and then show you where that file is in Windows Explorer…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s